Free guide — no signup

Should you repair or replace it?

The fridge died three days before the holiday and the tech quoted $600. New ones start around $900. Here's the rule the pros use, the real numbers by appliance, and a calculator that gives you a straight answer for your exact machine.

The 50% rule, in one line

Replace the appliance when it's past half its expected life AND the repair would cost more than half the price of a new one. If either number is well under 50%, repairing is almost always the better value. Past about 75% of the appliance's lifespan, lean toward replacing even for a cheaper fix — because more failures are usually right behind it. That's the whole rule. The rest is knowing the real numbers, which is where most people guess.

Lifespans, repair costs, and what a new one costs

Typical, national figures — brand, region, and condition move them. Lifespans are from the National Association of Home Builders; repair and replacement ranges are compiled from published appliance repair pricing guides — researched estimates, not a quote.

ApplianceTypical lifeCommon repairReplace (installed)Repair if…
Refrigerator~13 yr$200–$600$700–$2,500under ~7 yr & not the compressor
Washer~10 yr$150–$400$600–$1,300under ~7 yr & not the tub bearing
Dryer~13 yr$150–$450$600–$1,300most fixes — dryers are usually worth repairing
Dishwasher~9 yr$150–$600$600–$1,700under ~6 yr & not the control board
Oven / range~13–15 yr$150–$600$700–$1,600element/igniter/sensor — usually yes
Microwave~9 yr$75–$300$150–$600rarely — a magnetron ≈ a new microwave
Garbage disposal~12 yr$70–$400$150–$400a jam/reset yes; a leak often means replace
Freezer~12 yr$100–$400$400–$1,200under ~8 yr & not the sealed system

Want the verdict for your exact machine — with your quote and its age? Run the free calculator →

How to make the call in 30 seconds

1

Find the age

Check the purchase date or the manufacture date on the model/serial plate. Compare it to the typical lifespan above. Over ~75% of the way there tilts toward replace.

2

Get the repair quote

What did the tech say the fix costs, parts and labor? A sealed system, compressor, or tub bearing is the expensive category — a fan, valve, element, or thermostat is the cheap one.

3

Run the 50% check

If the repair is over half the price of a comparable new unit AND the appliance is past half its life, replace it. If not, fix it — a fair repair on a machine with life left is money well spent.

The repairs that usually mean "replace"

A few failures are expensive enough — or tell you enough about the machine — that replacing is usually the smarter money.

Refrigerator compressor / sealed system

$700–$1,250 and often EPA-regulated work. On a fridge past ~8 years, that's replacement territory. Note: sealed-system parts sometimes carry 5–10 year manufacturer coverage — check the brand's warranty first.

Front-load washer tub bearing

Labor-heavy and usually a sign the machine is near the end of its ~10-year life. Fixing it can cost a large share of a new washer.

Microwave magnetron

The part plus labor lands right at the price of a new countertop microwave. Built-in units are the exception and can be worth fixing.

Repair-or-replace FAQ

What is the 50% rule for appliances?

Replace the appliance when it has used at least half its expected lifespan AND the repair would cost at least half the price of a new one. If either is well under 50%, repairing is usually the better value. Past ~75% of the lifespan, lean toward replacing even for a cheaper repair.

Is it worth repairing a 10-year-old refrigerator?

Usually not, if the repair is more than about half the cost of a new one — a fridge averages ~13 years, so at 10 it's used most of its life. A cheap fix (fan, thermostat) can still be worth it; a compressor or sealed-system repair usually is not.

How long do major appliances last?

Per the National Association of Home Builders: refrigerator ~13 years, electric range ~13, gas range ~15, dryer ~13, garbage disposal ~12, washer ~10, dishwasher ~9, microwave ~9. Averages — brand, usage, and maintenance move them.

When should I replace an appliance instead of repairing it?

Three signals, and any one of them tips it: the repair runs more than half the price of a new unit, the appliance is past about 75% of its expected life, or the failure is one of the big-ticket ones above — a fridge compressor, a front-load tub bearing, a microwave magnetron.

Should I factor in energy savings?

Yes, on the margin. A much newer, efficient model can pay back part of its cost over time, especially for refrigerators and washers that run constantly. It rarely flips a clearly-worth-repairing fix into a replace, but it can tip a borderline call.

Every appliance, with its own numbers

The common failures, what each repair typically costs, and the verdict — jump to yours:

Refrigerator · Washing Machine · Dryer · Dishwasher · Oven / Range · Microwave · Freezer · Garbage Disposal

Is it worth repairing a refrigerator?

Repair a refrigerator when it is under about 8 years old and the fix is not the compressor. A fan motor, thermostat, or ice maker runs $200–$400 — cheap against a $700–$2,500 new fridge. But a compressor or sealed-system repair ($700+) on a fridge past 8 years is usually the replace conversation, because the appliance is near the end of its ~13-year life.

FailureTypical repairVerdict
Evaporator fan motor$250–$400usually repair
Main control board$200–$600depends on age
Ice maker assembly$200–$330usually repair
Defrost heater / thermostat$100–$250usually repair
Compressor / sealed system$700–$1,250usually replace

Typical life ~13 yr · a new one runs $700–$2,500 installed. Replace when the repair is over half that AND the refrigerator is past half its life. Run the numbers for yours →

Is it worth repairing a 10-year-old refrigerator?

Usually only for a cheap fix. At 10 years a fridge is past most of its ~13-year life, so a $700+ compressor or sealed-system repair is rarely worth it, but a $200–$400 fan, thermostat, or ice-maker repair often still is.

How much does it cost to fix a refrigerator?

Common refrigerator repairs run about $200–$600 (fan motors, control boards, ice makers, defrost parts). A compressor or sealed-system repair is the expensive category at $700–$1,250 and requires EPA-certified refrigerant work.

How long does a refrigerator last?

A refrigerator lasts about 13 years on average, per the National Association of Home Builders. Brand, usage, and whether the coils are kept clean move that number.

Should I repair or replace a refrigerator with a bad compressor?

On most refrigerators, a bad compressor is the replace conversation — the repair runs $700–$1,250 and often approaches the cost of a new unit. The exception is a fairly new, high-end fridge whose sealed system may still be under a 5–10 year manufacturer warranty; check that first.

Is it worth repairing a washing machine?

Repair a washing machine for a drain pump, door lock, or inlet valve — those run $100–$300, well under a $600–$1,300 new washer, and they are common on machines under 7 years old. The one that usually means replace is a tub-bearing failure on an older front-loader: it is a full teardown, the labor is what kills it, and washers only average ~10 years.

FailureTypical repairVerdict
Drain pump$150–$300usually repair
Door lock / lid switch$100–$200usually repair
Water inlet valve$100–$200usually repair
Tub bearing (front-load)$150–$400usually replace
Belt / suspension$100–$200usually repair

Typical life ~10 yr · a new one runs $600–$1,300 installed. Replace when the repair is over half that AND the washing machine is past half its life. Run the numbers for yours →

Is it worth repairing a washing machine?

For a drain pump, door lock, or inlet valve on a machine under about 7 years old, yes — those run $100–$300 against a $600–$1,300 new washer. A tub-bearing failure on an older front-loader usually is not worth fixing.

How much does it cost to repair a washing machine?

Most washing machine repairs run $100–$400. Drain pumps, valves, and switches are on the lower end; a front-load tub bearing is the expensive, labor-heavy repair.

How long does a washing machine last?

A washing machine lasts about 10 years on average, per the National Association of Home Builders. Front-loaders and top-loaders are similar; overloading and hard water shorten it.

Is a tub bearing worth fixing on a front-load washer?

Usually not. It is a full teardown of the machine — often three hours of labor — and the cost can approach a large share of a new washer, on a machine already near the end of its life. Run the replace math before committing to it.

Is it worth repairing a dryer?

A dryer is one of the most repair-worthy appliances in the house. Most fixes — heating element, belt, rollers, thermostat — run $80–$350, the mechanics are simple and durable, and dryers last about 13 years. Unless it is a drive-motor failure on a very old unit, repairing a dryer is almost always the smarter money.

FailureTypical repairVerdict
Heating element$150–$350usually repair
Belt$100–$200usually repair
Drum rollers / idler$120–$220usually repair
Thermal fuse / thermostat$80–$200usually repair
Drive motor$250–$450depends on age

Typical life ~13 yr · a new one runs $600–$1,300 installed. Replace when the repair is over half that AND the dryer is past half its life. Run the numbers for yours →

Is it worth repairing a dryer?

Almost always, yes. Most dryer repairs run $80–$350, the parts are simple and durable, and dryers last about 13 years. Only a drive-motor failure on a very old dryer starts to favor replacement.

How much does it cost to fix a dryer?

Common dryer repairs run about $80–$350 — heating element, belt, rollers, and thermostats are inexpensive. A drive motor is the priciest common repair at $250–$450.

My dryer is not heating — repair or replace?

Repair it. A no-heat dryer is usually a heating element, thermal fuse, or thermostat — $80–$350 — and those are among the most worthwhile appliance repairs there are.

How long does a dryer last?

A dryer lasts about 13 years on average, per the National Association of Home Builders. Cleaning the lint path and venting regularly extends it and prevents fire risk.

Is it worth repairing a dishwasher?

Repair a dishwasher under about 6 years old for a drain pump, heating element, or door latch — those run $75–$250. The repair that tips toward replacing is a control-board failure ($200–$600) on a dishwasher near its ~9-year average life, where the fix can approach a large share of a new one.

FailureTypical repairVerdict
Drain pump$150–$250usually repair
Heating element$150–$250usually repair
Control board$200–$600depends on age
Door latch$75–$150usually repair

Typical life ~9 yr · a new one runs $600–$1,700 installed. Replace when the repair is over half that AND the dishwasher is past half its life. Run the numbers for yours →

Is it worth repairing a dishwasher?

Under about 6 years old, yes for a drain pump, heating element, or door latch ($75–$250). A control-board failure ($200–$600) on a dishwasher near its ~9-year life often tips toward replacing.

How much does it cost to repair a dishwasher?

Most dishwasher repairs run $75–$600. Pumps, elements, and latches are inexpensive; the control board is the costly repair.

How long does a dishwasher last?

A dishwasher lasts about 9 years on average, per the National Association of Home Builders — the shortest of the major kitchen appliances.

My dishwasher will not drain — repair or replace?

Repair it. A dishwasher that will not drain is usually a drain pump or a clog — a $150–$250 fix — which is well worth it on nearly any dishwasher under 6 or 7 years old.

Is it worth repairing an oven or range?

Repair an oven or range for a bake element, gas igniter, or temperature sensor — those run $100–$300 and ovens last 13–15 years, so most are worth fixing. The exception is a control-board failure ($200–$600) on an older or high-end range, where the part cost starts to rival a replacement.

FailureTypical repairVerdict
Bake element$150–$300usually repair
Gas igniter$100–$250usually repair
Temp sensor / thermostat$100–$300usually repair
Control board$200–$600depends on age

Typical life ~14 yr · a new one runs $700–$1,600 installed. Replace when the repair is over half that AND the oven or range is past half its life. Run the numbers for yours →

Is it worth repairing an oven?

Usually yes. A bake element, gas igniter, or temperature sensor runs $100–$300, and ovens last 13–15 years. Only a control-board failure on an older or high-end range starts to favor replacing.

My oven is not heating — repair or replace?

Repair it. A no-heat electric oven is usually a bake element ($150–$300); a gas oven that will not light is usually the igniter ($100–$250). Both are worthwhile fixes on nearly any oven.

How much does it cost to fix an oven or range?

Common oven repairs run $100–$300 for elements, igniters, and sensors. A control board is the expensive repair at $200–$600.

How long does an oven or range last?

An electric range lasts about 13 years and a gas range about 15, per the National Association of Home Builders.

Is it worth repairing a microwave?

For most countertop microwaves, replace rather than repair — a magnetron (the part that fails when it stops heating) plus labor lands right at the price of a new unit that starts around $150. A door switch or turntable motor is cheap enough to fix, and built-in or over-range microwaves — which cost far more to replace — are worth repairing.

FailureTypical repairVerdict
Magnetron (no heat)$100–$300usually replace
Door switch$75–$150depends on age
Turntable motor / diode$75–$200depends on age

Typical life ~9 yr · a new one runs $150–$600 installed. Replace when the repair is over half that AND the microwave is past half its life. Run the numbers for yours →

Is it worth repairing a microwave?

For a countertop microwave, usually not — a magnetron repair plus labor approaches the cost of a new unit that starts around $150. Built-in and over-range microwaves cost far more to replace, so those are worth fixing.

My microwave stopped heating — repair or replace?

On a countertop unit, replace it. A microwave that runs but will not heat is usually a failed magnetron, and that repair costs about what a new countertop microwave does. A built-in is the exception worth fixing.

How much does it cost to fix a microwave?

Microwave repairs run $75–$300. A door switch or turntable motor is cheap; a magnetron is the costly one that usually favors replacement on countertop units.

How long does a microwave last?

A microwave lasts about 9 years on average, per the National Association of Home Builders.

Is it worth repairing a freezer?

Repair a standalone freezer for a door gasket, defrost system, or thermostat — those run $100–$400 and freezers last about 12 years. The repair that tips toward replacing is a sealed-system or compressor failure, which on a freezer past 8 years usually costs more than a new one is worth.

FailureTypical repairVerdict
Door gasket$100–$250usually repair
Defrost system$100–$250usually repair
Control / thermostat$150–$400depends on age

Typical life ~12 yr · a new one runs $400–$1,200 installed. Replace when the repair is over half that AND the freezer is past half its life. Run the numbers for yours →

Is it worth repairing a freezer?

For a door gasket, defrost part, or thermostat, yes — those run $100–$400 against a $400–$1,200 new freezer. A sealed-system or compressor failure on a freezer past 8 years usually is not worth it.

My freezer is not freezing — repair or replace?

It depends on the cause. A defrost or thermostat problem is a $100–$400 fix worth doing. A sealed-system failure — where the compressor runs but nothing gets cold — is usually the replace conversation on an older freezer.

How long does a freezer last?

A standalone freezer lasts about 12 years on average, per the National Association of Home Builders. Chest freezers often outlast uprights.

How much does it cost to repair a freezer?

Common freezer repairs run $100–$400 for gaskets, defrost parts, and thermostats. Sealed-system work is the expensive, often replace-instead category.

Is it worth repairing a garbage disposal?

A jammed or tripped garbage disposal is a cheap fix — often a $70–$150 reset or clog clearing worth doing on any unit. But a disposal that leaks from the body, or a motor that hums and will not turn, usually means replacement: a new disposal installed runs $150–$400, close to what a major repair would cost.

FailureTypical repairVerdict
Jam / reset / clog$70–$150usually repair
Body leak / dead motor$150–$400usually replace

Typical life ~12 yr · a new one runs $150–$400 installed. Replace when the repair is over half that AND the garbage disposal is past half its life. Run the numbers for yours →

Is it worth repairing a garbage disposal?

A jam, reset, or clog is worth clearing — a $70–$150 fix. But a leak from the disposal body or a dead motor usually means replacing it, since a new unit installed runs $150–$400, about what the repair would cost.

My garbage disposal is leaking — repair or replace?

If it leaks from the body or the internal seals, replace it — those leaks are not economically repairable. A leak at a hose or mounting connection can sometimes be fixed for less.

My disposal hums but will not spin — repair or replace?

First try the reset button and free the jam with the hex wrench — that fixes most of these for the cost of a service call. If it still hums with a free flywheel, the motor is done and it needs replacing.

How long does a garbage disposal last?

A garbage disposal lasts about 12 years on average, per the National Association of Home Builders.

Get a straight answer for your machine

The free appliance repair calculator takes your appliance, the failure, your quote, and its age, and gives you a repair-or-replace verdict with the math shown — no signup. Fix appliances for a living? See how SideWRK works for appliance repair.

Run the calculator →

Are you the repair tech? SideWRK prices the repair, shows the customer the repair-or-replace verdict, and turns it into a professional invoice — see SideWRK for appliance repair →

Fix these for a living?

SideWRK runs an appliance repair business from your phone — flat-rate invoices with the service-call fee credited, billable mileage, truck stock that warns before you run out, and the honest warranty check that earns the next call.

The appliance repair app Repair cost checker

Free tool · no signup · runs in your browserTry it free